Colossus wants some opinions!

[Colossus]

My roommate and I have a YouTube channel around drinking and gaming. We call it Games and Growlers.
Today, I came up with one idea and my roommate came up with another (I created both).
Not saying who came up with what, but I would like opinions from this community (exclusively this community!) to see what everyone else thinks. 
These are for the Icon in our channel to identify who we are. 

Buttons:


Controller: 


Ignore sizes. Color will not be blue or green, but clear. I have the colors to make them clearer on here.

[SamuraiGaiden]

I think I like the one with the controller on it better. Looks more like a brand label on the bottle.

[Kakariko Kid]

Agreed. The one with the controller is better, imo. The top one would look more like a Gameboy layout if the buttons were with the bottom more to the left and the top more to the right.

[Colossus]

The buttons one I did pretty quick. I just threw everything in there where they seemed to fit better.